Considering a clarifier

TroubleFreePat

0
LifeTime Supporter
Jun 5, 2013
197
Philadelphia, PA
Surface
Fiberglass
Chlorine
Salt Water Generator
Have had the pool for about 10 years now. Have used the TFP method since day one and it's never disappointed.

Several years ago, I noticed (Primarily) when it's night and the pool lights are on, there's a lot of particles floating by the pool lights. I can also see them during the day if I'm swimming with goggles. TINY. I figure dust, pollen, etc.

Chemistry is good. Never had an algae incident in the pool (That I'm aware of) and over the years, have had to SLAM a time or two due to FC getting low and/or initial startup. These particles have never gone away. I posted a video on here years ago and we never could come up with anything. Even purchased a new filter thinking maybe I had a hole I couldn't see/find, but no change. Also use a skimmer sock (At least this time of year with all the pollen.)

The perfectionist in me wants them to go away. I've been reading about using a chitosan clarifier and seems most on here are okay with it in situations where you might have construction dust or similar in the pool. While the filter should get it eventually, even when I've run my pump on full blast for a few days to see if it would clear, no change. So clarifier? Wouldn't be a regular use thing. Either it's going to work or it won't; if it does, maybe I use it in a few years again.

I saw Leslie's had clarifier on sale and picked on up (Only time I've been there) and THEN found out about polymers vs chitosan. So that's getting returned. I see the SeaKlear clarifier recommended on occasion, and even found someone that uses a clarifier from orenda called CE-Clarifier that also has an enzyme in it to work on oils and non-living organics. We're not heavy on sunscreen luckily. But if the only downside is cost, I'm willing to give it a shot one time.

One thing to note - I have an auto-cover. Pool is almost always closed unless it's being used or we're outside hanging out. So not a lot of sunlight hitting it. In one thread I read from chem geek years ago, he mentioned about a properly dosed pool (re: FC) and having the pool open to sunlight regularly around a subject of the breakdown of chlorine producing hydroxyl radicals that are short-lived but powerful oxidizers. I'm probably not getting that reaction. Not sure how much it matters for my particular question. . .

Did put borates in many years ago - never really saw a difference, so never added them again.

So now I turn to you. I never put anything in the water that's not recommended, and I've never seen anything written about this mystery enzyme. Any details from the wizards?
 
That type of turbidity is completely normal for an outdoor pool. No residential outdoor pool will ever be perfectly clear at night. The pool light is reflected from particulates and gas bubbles in the water in a way that highlights them as opposed to pure daylight which’s strikes particles at all angles. This is why they are so prominent around a pool light.

The clarifier will not make the problem go away. It might minimize the issue a bit, but the moment you stop using it, the “problem” will come right back. It’s simply the nature of outdoor pools. And your autocover is not a perfect seal so anything that gets dragged in and out of the pool on the cover will create particulates. You also have a fiberglass pool and FG surfaces shed particulates over time.

Sorry, but if I’m being honest with you, the problem is you and not the pool. You said it yourself, your OCD makes it bothersome to you. But that’s not the pools fault … just sayin’ …
 
  • Like
Reactions: reggiehammond
The particles that are too heavy to float, yet too light to sink to the bottom, can sit suspended in the water for days. By the time they catch the right current to the skimmer, it was breezy and 3 more rounds blew in. Its a neverending cycle with less in the mid season and more in the spring/fall.

Let's say you used a clarifier and it worked today. It'll be breezy soon enough and they'll all be back. Probably even before you get to enjoy the perfect water.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoyfulNoise
Might have to do another just to see if we’re all on the same page.
We're on the same page. If you can see it, it is far larger than needed for the filter to grab it, once given the chance. It's your yards fault, not the filters. And it could take days for those suspended particles to catch the right current to the filter. In the meantime it was breezy again and it never ends. Lol.

It should die down some for the midseason. The fall will probably look like the spring.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.