Pool Math LC Addition Calculation Incorrect

thecabana

Active member
Jul 24, 2022
29
Austin, TX
Hey all. Unsure what to do here.

I am using 12.5% Blue Whale liquid chlorine (from Leslie's). I checked the box, and the manufacturer date is very recent (sometime in mid February 2025), and I store it in a dark closet, so I doubt degradation is an issue.

When calculating on pool math to raise the FC level, my first reading this morning it was at 6.6ppm. I had it calculate a suggestion to get to 10ppm (my CYA is 70). Added 62 fl oz as recommended. Tested 60 minutes later, FC level is only 8.4ppm. This has been consistently an issue since I started testing regularly in February, and it's making it difficult to keep my FC consistent because I don't think I'm ever adding enough.

But I think my pool gallons are correct (17,700). I have the original information from the pool builder, and I don't have this issue with adding other chemicals to the pool. When I added dry stabilizer in February, the suggested amount from pool math to add for 17,700 gallons was pretty spot on for what I got (if not, ended up a hair higher ppm than expected - rather than low, like the chlorine).

To get to the "correct" chlorine ppm by adjusting my gallons, I'd have to essentially nearly double the gallons in my pool, which I just don't think is correct.

Any thoughts or suggestions? Could the chlorine I'm getting just be crappy? TIA!!
 
The calculation is correct for 12.5% liquid chlorine to add 3.4 ppm FC to a 17,000 gallon pool.

If you are adding 62 ounces and only seeing a 1.8 ppm rise then one of a few things is amiss: 1, your chlorine is only 6%. 2, Your pool is actually 34,000 gallons. Or 3, there's something else going on with your water.

Of the options I'm heavily leaning towards the first one. It would be unlikely to be off by double on pool size, and for something to eat through several ppm of chlorine in an hour but then leave it alone for the rest of the day would be a new one even for us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newdude
The calculation is correct for 12.5% liquid chlorine to add 3.4 ppm FC to a 17,000 gallon pool.

If you are adding 62 ounces and only seeing a 1.8 ppm rise then one of a few things is amiss: 1, your chlorine is only 6%. 2, Your pool is actually 34,000 gallons. Or 3, there's something else going on with your water.

Of the options I'm heavily leaning towards the first one. It would be unlikely to be off by double on pool size, and for something to eat through several ppm of chlorine in an hour but then leave it alone for the rest of the day would be a new one even for us.
Thank you! Yes this is what I suspect...is it possible that the chlorine manufactured just a month ago is 6% rather than the labeled 12.5%? Have you seen that before? It seems the most plausible to me because the chemicals other than liquid chlorine added are resulting in the correct expected ppm, and I don't recall this issue with the pool math suggested amounts last year. But it's wild to me the liquid chlorine could be SO off without being old!
 
.is it possible that the chlorine manufactured just a month ago is 6% rather than the labeled 12.5%? Have you seen that before? It seems the most plausible to me
With the current state of quality control ? Please don't even get me started. :ROFLMAO:


It could also be from the store. They may have left the pallet baking in the sun out back for 2 weeks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sws and thecabana
  • Like
Reactions: thecabana

Enjoying this content?

Support TFP with a donation.

Give Support
TFP is a registered 501(c)3 non-profit that is maintained by user donations.

The people who answer questions are volunteers.

If you find the site to be a good resource, please consider making a donation to help support the site.

Thanks.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Sws and oledan