Low Calcium Reason for Cloudy Water?

Apr 18, 2017
25
Alexandria, LA
Hey everyone, very happy to wake up this morning to Crystal clear water for the first time in a month of finding this community and learning about chemicals and chemistry.

To recap, I have been steady slamming for about a month on a swamp. Finally got to where I passed the overnight chlorine loss test, but still had milky water even with constant backwashing. I just learned about my low Calcium levels and how it has been damaging the plaster in my pool, nothing terrible, just not quite as pretty as it should be. I was at 60 ppm calcium hardness, added approximately 25 lbs of calcium chloride yesterday. I woke up this morning to Crystal clear water. The only factor that changed from yesterday to this morning was the addition of calcium.

And this wasn't a gradual change. I couldn't put a dent in the cloudiness, even tried to do a deep clean of filter, only to find out i need to cut the pipes and add unions, so that is on my project list for the future. Just wondering if the the low Calcium could have been the sole reason of the cloudy water, or was it just a big coincidence that the chlorine finally won the pool the same night as i added the calcium.

I have a second question about testing for calcium. When I add the second set of drops that change it to red, it's a very pale shade. When i watched a person test on YouTube, it turns a bright red, then goes to a bright blue. Before when I had low Calcium, it would be a light shade of red, then after 6 drops went to a light shade of blue. After adding calcium chloride, when i tested this morning, it still was a light shade of red, but took 36 drops to get it to a light shade of blue. I assumed that when I got my calcium up the colors in the test would be more pronounced.

f368191ccbb733dd19b5e90426727877.jpg


~11,500 gallon in-ground 27 x 13 ft
3 ft in shallow, 5.5 ft in deep
Plaster bottom/fiberglass sides(?)
 
You can see that at that very low CH you had before, your CSI value was well below -0.6, about -1.0 . This was likely leeching calcium from your pool walls to the extent that it was clouding the water. I'm sure the addition of CH you performed can entirely explain why the clouding went away.

The similar appearance of the color change is normal and only a function of the indicator added, not the level of calcium present.
 
You can see that at that very low CH you had before, your CSI value was well below -0.6, about -1.0 . This was likely leeching calcium from your pool walls to the extent that it was clouding the water. I'm sure the addition of CH you performed can entirely explain why the clouding went away.
Thanks. It didn't scar the plaster too bad, but hate the way it looks now. Guess I'll never make that mistake again.

~11,500 gallon in-ground 27 x 13 ft
3 ft in shallow, 5.5 ft in deep
Plaster bottom/fiberglass sides(?)
 
Breaks my heart to see my poor plaster be sent out the backwash. This pool chemistry thing can be overwhelming for a first time pool owner. I wish i would have found this community when we first bought the house. On the positive note, you can see the water is Crystal. Is the loss of plaster anything you all would worry about?
b968b40bc40a2b8adcc669f3d6d5fe6c.jpg
12c34ec3e27c3a49b79d12acc4ddf2f6.jpg


~11,500 gallon in-ground 27 x 13 ft
3 ft in shallow, 5.5 ft in deep
Plaster bottom/fiberglass sides(?)
 
I'm not a plaster expert by any means (vinyl pool myself). However, the plaster layer of your pool is mostly aesthetic but does provide the non-porous layer to keep water in the pool. Less porous than the gunite behind the plaster. If you're not seeing any brown or rust colored staining coming through the plaster, seeing visible gunite or losing water, it's probably fine. The texture of the plaster may have been affected but you should be OK now that you're maintaining proper chemistry.
 
Thread Status
Hello , This thread has been inactive for over 60 days. New postings here are unlikely to be seen or responded to by other members. For better visibility, consider Starting A New Thread.